Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

What exposure therapy involves, and why avoidance backfires

Why dodging a feared situation keeps the fear going, what a graded exposure plan looks like step by step, and when it is not the place to start.

Published

The 7.42 pulls in. You are on the platform with your bag on your shoulder and your heart going hard, and when the doors open you stay where you are. The train leaves. Within a minute your chest loosens, your hands stop prickling, and you walk back to the car park to drive in instead.

That relief is real. It arrives quickly and it is reliable, and that is the trouble with it. Anything that works that well, you will do again tomorrow.

Why does avoiding it keep the fear going?

When you step back from something you fear, two things happen. The anxiety falls, which teaches you that stepping back works. And you never find out what would have happened if you had stayed. The prediction ("I'll panic and I won't be able to get off") is left untested, ready for next time. In the cognitive behavioural account of anxiety, this is why a fear can last for years: people steer around the situations that set it off, so the fear never gets the chance to fade.

Staying off the train is the obvious version. The quieter versions are called safety behaviours: only travelling with a partner, sitting beside the doors, having a couple of drinks before a flight, carrying a tablet "just in case". With these in place you can get through the situation, but the prop gets the credit. The feeling afterwards is of having got away with it, and the fear is back at full strength the first day the prop is missing.

What does a graded plan look like?

Exposure therapy is the deliberate reverse: approaching what you fear, on purpose, in a planned order. A psychologist will first want to know exactly what you expect to happen, and every way you currently get around the situation, including the subtle ones. They should also explain the reasoning well enough that it makes sense to you, because the plan depends on you carrying it out between appointments.

Then the two of you build a list and rate each item from 0 to 100 for the distress you expect. Take, as a made-up example, a woman who has not caught a train for two years. Her list might run:

  1. Standing on the platform while two trains come and go: 30
  2. One stop, off-peak, with her sister: 40
  3. One stop, off-peak, alone, in a seat by the doors: 50
  4. Three stops alone, seated in the middle of the carriage: 65
  5. A stretch with ten minutes between stations: 80
  6. A crowded peak-hour train to the city, standing, alone: 95

The usual starting point is an item rated around 50, which is moderate, because an early success tends to build confidence. Starting at the top (called flooding) is not usual, because most people find working up in steps easier to accept.

Before each step she states her prediction: what will happen, how soon, and how sure she is. Say it is "I'll panic so badly I'll have to get off before the second stop, and I'm 80 per cent sure." The task is then to stay on past the second stop, and not to get off at the first dip in anxiety. Afterwards they go over what happened, and she rates the prediction again.

Over the following weeks the props come off one at a time: a seat away from the doors, the phone zipped in the bag, no sister. (Whether to keep taking a prescribed medicine is a separate question, and one for the doctor who prescribed it.) The lines and times of day change too. Where possible the first exposure is done with the psychologist, out where the anxiety happens and not only in an office. But she also practises alone between sessions from the start, because a psychologist standing nearby can become one more prop.

What are you supposed to learn from it?

Most people assume the aim is to feel calm on the train. That is not quite it. The research on whether a drop in fear during exposure predicts how well treatment goes is mixed. So a step is judged by whether your prediction was tested and whether you stayed with the fear while it was. Someone who was anxious for the whole trip and stayed on has had a useful session.

Two things are learnt this way: the outcome you predicted did not happen, and you can tolerate being frightened. This is also why people are usually asked not to use slow breathing to get through an exposure. If you breathe your way through, the breathing gets the credit.

The current understanding is that exposure does not erase the old fear. It lays new learning over the top, and the old fear can resurface after a long gap or in an unfamiliar setting. That is the reason for practising in varied places, and for continuing to catch trains after therapy has finished.

What is it like to do?

Uncomfortable, and there is no honest way around saying so. What it should never be is a surprise. Each step is chosen together and explained beforehand, including how distressing it is likely to be. A rule of thumb in the clinical literature is that a step should be something most people would do, or would consider reasonable. Situations that carry real danger do not go on the list.

Who is it used for?

The form depends on what is feared. For feared places and situations it is done in real life. For panic, where the fear is of the body's own sensations, it includes bringing those sensations on deliberately, for instance by running on the spot or breathing through a straw. For obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) it is paired with choosing not to carry out the ritual, which is called exposure and response prevention. Where the feared thing cannot be set up in real life, such as a traumatic memory, it is done in imagination. With children, the list is drawn up by the child and a parent together.

The Australian Psychological Society's 2024 evidence review found Level I evidence (meaning support from systematic reviews of randomised trials) for exposure therapy for specific phobia in adults, and for cognitive behaviour therapy with exposure and response prevention for OCD in adults, children and adolescents. It found the same level for cognitive behaviour therapy, which usually includes exposure, for panic disorder and social anxiety disorder in adults, and the UK's NICE guidelines endorse it as a first-line treatment for social anxiety disorder. The Australian PTSD guidelines recommend prolonged exposure for adults with PTSD. None of this evidence says how any one person will go.

When is it not the right first step?

  • New physical symptoms. A racing heart, palpitations or breathlessness that have started recently should be checked by a GP before they are treated as anxiety. An overactive thyroid can produce the same symptoms, and so can a lot of caffeine.
  • Severe depression. Where someone is very depressed, particularly with thoughts of suicide, the guidance for PTSD and OCD is that the depression may need treating first. In an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.
  • No real wish to do it. Guidance on OCD treatment is that someone attending only because a partner or parent insists is less likely to benefit, and that it can be better to wait.
  • Too frightened to begin. If even the lowest item on the list is out of reach, the first steps can be taken in imagination.

None of this makes the first trip pleasant. What changes is what the discomfort is for. Walking back to the car buys relief that lasts until the next train. Staying on past the second stop buys evidence, which is the one thing avoidance never lets you collect.

References

  1. Evidence-based Psychological Interventions in the Treatment of Mental Disorders: A Literature Review (5th ed.). Australian Psychological Society, 2024
  2. Australian Guidelines for the Prevention and Treatment of Acute Stress Disorder, Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Complex PTSD. Phoenix Australia, 2020 (with later updates)
  3. Social anxiety disorder: recognition, assessment and treatment (Clinical guideline CG159). National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), 2013

Make an appointment

Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.

Back to blog