What "confidential" really means when you see a psychologist
What a psychologist in Victoria keeps private, the few situations where they may or must share it, and what happens to your records.
Published
Two people sit in the same waiting room before a first appointment. One assumes that whatever she says in there is sealed for good. The other has heard that psychologists "have to report things", so he has already decided which parts of his life to leave out. Both are working from a guess, and both guesses are wrong.
The actual rules are few and specific, and worth knowing before you sit down, because they bear on what you choose to say. This is written for Victoria. Where another state differs in a way that matters, it says so. It is general information, not legal advice.
The default is that what you say stays with your psychologist
Under the Code of conduct for psychologists, you have a right to expect that information about you is held securely and in confidence. Two things can displace that: a law that requires or permits the information to be released, and the need to get emergency services to someone.
In practice:
- If someone rings asking about you, your psychologist should neither confirm nor deny that you are a client.
- Your psychologist should not contact your partner or a parent for background unless you know about it first.
- Sharing your information needs your written consent, even with your name removed. The Psychology Board says this includes sharing it in supervision or with a colleague, so you may be asked about that at the start.
- The obligation continues after you stop attending, and after death. In Victoria, rights over a deceased person's health record pass to the executor or administrator of the estate, not to relatives generally.
Some disclosures are required by law
Here the psychologist has no discretion.
Children at risk. Registered psychologists in Victoria are mandatory reporters. If, through their work, a psychologist comes to believe on reasonable grounds that a child has suffered, or is likely to suffer, significant harm from physical injury or sexual abuse, and that the child's parents have not protected them or are unlikely to, the psychologist must report it to child protection. The test is a reasonable belief, not proof. Every state and territory has its own version of this duty, and they differ on who must report and what.
Victoria also has a criminal law requiring any adult who reasonably believes that an adult has sexually offended against a child under 16 to tell police, unless they have a reasonable excuse. It has exceptions, and one covers what a person who was abused tells their treating doctor or psychologist in confidence.
Courts. A subpoena can require a psychologist to produce your records or give evidence. The psychologist cannot refuse simply because the sessions were confidential, but can ask the court to consider an objection before anyone inspects the material, and would normally tell you promptly so you can get legal advice.
Clients who are health practitioners. If you are a registered health practitioner yourself, national law can require your treating psychologist to notify Ahpra about you. The bar is set very high on purpose (broadly, that you are placing the public at substantial risk of harm), so that practitioners can get treatment without fearing a report. It is lower for sexual misconduct connected with practice.
Others are permitted, and the psychologist has to judge
People most often get this part wrong. When a client may seriously harm themselves or someone else, a psychologist is generally permitted to break confidentiality, not obliged to. The Commonwealth Privacy Act allows disclosure where it is unreasonable or impracticable to get your consent and the psychologist reasonably believes it is necessary to lessen or prevent a serious threat to someone's life, health or safety. Victoria's Health Records Act has a similar test. New South Wales and the ACT are narrower: the threat must be serious and imminent.
Permitted does not mean automatic. The Code expects a psychologist to take reasonable steps about the risk, and disclosure is only one of them. Professional guidelines say to assess first (how likely, how serious, how soon) and to look for ways of protecting people that do not go around you: a safety plan, you telling someone yourself, you agreeing to a call to your GP. Someone who says after a humiliating meeting that she could strangle her manager is in a different position from someone who has a weapon and knows where that person will be on Friday.
Likewise, saying that you have had thoughts of suicide does not by itself send your psychologist to the phone. It leads to more questions about how serious and how close the risk is. Where there is immediate danger, the Code allows the psychologist to give emergency services what they need to reach you. If you or someone else is in immediate danger, call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.
Firearms law differs by state. In Victoria, a psychologist who believes a client is not a fit and proper person to have a firearm may advise the Chief Commissioner of Police. Tasmania and the Northern Territory make a report compulsory in some circumstances.
Where it is safe, you should be told beforehand what will be shared and why.
Reports to a GP, an insurer or anyone else
Some sharing comes with the funding. If you see a psychologist under Medicare on a GP's mental health treatment plan, the psychologist is obliged to report briefly to the GP on your treatment. Workers compensation insurers, the NDIS and employee assistance programs can carry reporting conditions of their own. You should hear about these before you agree to start. If there is something particular you do not want passed on, say so: the guidelines tell psychologists to be clear about exactly that.
Anyone else, whether an employer, a school, a lawyer or a relative, needs your consent. Expect to be asked again when a request arrives, because consent has to be current, and specific about what goes to whom.
What happens to your record
The Code requires your record to be factual and objective, with no demeaning remarks, and you can ask to see it. In Victoria the practice must respond within 45 days. Access can be refused only on limited grounds, such as a serious threat to someone's life, health or safety, or an unreasonable impact on another person's privacy. A refusal must be in writing and tell you how to complain. You can also ask for errors to be corrected.
In Victoria an adult's record must be kept for at least seven years after the last service, and a record made in childhood until the person turns 25, or seven years after the last service if that is later. It cannot be destroyed earlier, even at your request.
Recording or transcribing a session, including with an AI tool, calls for your written consent first under professional guidelines, and you can withdraw it. A Victorian practice must also give its written policy on managing health information to anyone who asks.
Why all this is explained at the start
The Code says clients should be told the limits of confidentiality at the beginning of a service, and again as needed. The guidelines add plain language, a check that you have understood, and the point that a form sent in advance cannot replace the conversation. So expect a few minutes of the first session to go on this, out loud.
You can only decide what to say if you know where it can go. A psychologist who promises that nothing will ever leave the room is promising something the law does not let them deliver, and one who skips the subject leaves you guessing. The man in the waiting room had one thing right: what he says is his to decide. He should get to decide it knowing the rules.
References
- Code of conduct for psychologists. Psychology Board of Australia
- Code of conduct: frequently asked questions. Psychology Board of Australia
- Privacy Act 1988 (Cth). Federal Register of Legislation
- Health Records Act 2001 (Vic). Victorian Legislation
- Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic). Victorian Legislation
Make an appointment
Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.