Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

What an IQ test actually measures, and what it can't tell you

What happens in a cognitive assessment for a child or adult, what the scores mean, and why the pattern across areas matters more than one number.

Published

Two children can both score 104 on an IQ test and have very little in common as learners. One scores close to 104 in every area the test covers. The other reasons with words well above most children their age and gets through simple timed tasks well below them, and the two average out to the same figure. For the first child, 104 is a fair description. For the second, it describes no part of how they actually think.

That is worth knowing before you book a cognitive assessment, the formal name for what most people call an IQ test. Most families expect to leave with one number. The number exists, and some decisions require it. But what explains why school or work is hard usually sits in the pattern underneath, and even the pattern is a set of leads to check, not a verdict.

What the session is like

The test is given one-to-one, at a table. For children aged 6 to 16 the usual choice is the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (the WISC). From 16 to 90 it is the adult version (the WAIS).

The session is a run of short, varied activities: spoken questions, puzzles with shapes and pictures, memory tasks, and quick pencil-and-paper tasks against a timer. For a child, the ten main activities take about 65 minutes on average. Among adults, half finish the core activities in about 67 minutes and nearly all within 100. The aim is one sitting, with breaks.

You may notice the psychologist reading instructions word for word and declining to give hints. A score only means something if the tasks were given exactly as they were to the people the test was first tried out on. For the same reason, anything that could have affected the day is recorded and weighed when the results are read: a night shift, pain, a child who became upset partway through.

The areas a cognitive test measures

The children's test reports five areas. The current adult test reports four, treating the second and third below as one.

  • Verbal comprehension. Word knowledge and reasoning in words.
  • Visual spatial. Seeing how shapes and parts fit together.
  • Fluid reasoning. Working out the rule behind a problem you have not met before, without leaning on what you were taught.
  • Working memory. Holding information in mind for a short time and doing something with it. In a classroom it shows up in following an instruction that has several steps.
  • Processing speed. How quickly and accurately a person gets through simple visual tasks with a pencil, under time pressure.

Each area is scored on the same scale as the overall IQ, where 100 is the midpoint for the person's age and 90 to 109 is labelled average. Each also comes with a percentile. A score of 120 sits at the 91st percentile, meaning the person did better than 91 in every 100 people their age. It does not mean 91 per cent of the answers were correct.

Why a single score can mislead

Take a hypothetical ten-year-old referred because he is slow to finish written work. His results are 118 for verbal comprehension, 109 for visual spatial, 112 for fluid reasoning, 88 for working memory and 83 for processing speed. His overall IQ is 104, which is average.

Reported alone, 104 suggests there is nothing to explain. Read as a profile, the same results say he reasons in words better than most children his age and gets work onto paper more slowly than most. The distance between the two may be what his teacher has noticed. When areas are this far apart, the test's manual recommends that the area scores, not the overall IQ, carry the interpretation. One published guide to the adult test goes further: if the highest and lowest areas differ by 23 points or more, the overall IQ should not be presented as a summary of ability at all.

No score is exact: a measured IQ of 106 might properly be read as "probably between 102 and 110", and a report should print that range. And a gap can be real without being unusual. Uneven profiles turn up often among people with no difficulties, so the psychologist checks how common a gap of that size is before reading anything into it.

A pattern is a lead, not a diagnosis

A low processing speed score can come from slow thinking speed. It can also come from trouble telling similar shapes apart, difficulty controlling a pencil, a slow and careful style of deciding, or attention that wanders. The number cannot say which. That is worked out from how the person went about the tasks, their history, and what parents, teachers or a partner describe.

This matters most for a question many families bring: do the results show ADHD? They cannot. In research, children with ADHD have tended to score lower on working memory and processing speed, but so have children with learning disorders and autism. When the children's test was trialled with 25 Australian and New Zealand children diagnosed with ADHD (most were taking medication at the time), their average in every area was still within the average range. Low scores in those areas do not establish ADHD, and average scores do not rule it out. The Australian ADHD guideline bases assessment on a developmental and clinical history, reports from people who see the person in daily life, standardised rating scales, and a medical assessment to exclude other causes.

Learning difficulties work the same way. A cognitive test does not measure how well someone reads, spells or does school maths, so if a specific learning disorder is the question, an achievement test is added and the two are read together with the school history.

The comparison group has limits

Every score compares one person with a reference group, so it matters who was in it. The children's test was standardised on 528 Australian and New Zealand children matched to the census. Children whose main language was not English were left out, and only 22 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children were included, in a sample not designed to represent them. Australian guidance notes that tests leaning heavily on verbal content and timing may disadvantage Aboriginal people. For a child still learning English, the verbal scores are hard to interpret, and no test, picture-based ones included, is free of culture.

The adult test had its wording and pictures adapted for Australia and New Zealand, but its comparison group is still 2,200 people tested in the United States in 2007 and 2008, and research suggests that ageing norms make scores come out somewhat high. A careful report says who the comparison group was and how much weight the numbers can bear for this person.

What you receive afterwards

Two things: a conversation and a document. In the feedback session the psychologist explains the three or four findings that matter most, in plain language, tied to examples from the person's own life. You can ask questions and bring a support person.

The written report gives each score with its range, percentile and a plain-word descriptor. It answers the question that prompted the assessment and makes recommendations that are realistic for home, school or work. Unless the law requires otherwise, it goes only to the people you name in writing. A school receives the report, not the test booklets or raw answer sheets, because test content has to stay protected.

If the person has been tested before, say so. Sitting the same test again within about a year tends to lift scores through familiarity.

The most useful question to bring to the feedback session is rarely "what was the number?". Ask what the pattern suggested, and what it was checked against.

References

  1. Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Fifth Edition: Australian and New Zealand Standardised Edition (WISC-V A&NZ). Pearson Clinical Assessment, 2016
  2. Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Fourth Edition: Australian and New Zealand Language Adapted Edition (WAIS-IV A&NZ). Pearson Clinical Assessment
  3. Australian Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline for ADHD: Summary of recommendations. Australian ADHD Professionals Association, 2022
  4. Working Together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Mental Health and Wellbeing Principles and Practice (2nd ed.). Dudgeon, Milroy and Walker (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, 2014

Book an assessment

Choose a time online, or ask us a question first.

Book an assessment

Back to blog