Will my teenager's psychologist tell me what they talk about?
How a teenager's ability to consent is judged, what parents are usually told, and when a psychologist will tell you for safety reasons.
Published
At a teenager's first appointment, the same question tends to get asked twice. The parent asks it at the door, quietly: "You'll let me know what she says, won't you?" The teenager asks it a few minutes later, once the door is shut: "Are you going to tell my mum?"
Neither gets a flat yes or a flat no. If you are the parent, this is what the answer is, including the parts you may not like.
Can a teenager see a psychologist without a parent's consent?
Sometimes. There is no birthday on which it becomes allowed. Australian law uses a test of understanding instead, usually called the mature minor or Gillick principle, which the High Court adopted in 1992. A young person can consent to their own care once they have enough understanding and intelligence to understand fully what is proposed.
The psychologist judges that by talking with your teenager, and records the judgement. Australian Psychological Society guidance lists what they are checking the young person can understand:
- what the service is;
- its benefits and risks;
- what is likely to follow from having it, and from not having it;
- what it means to give consent and to take it back;
- where confidentiality stops.
The bar is high, and it rises with what is at stake. A 15-year-old may well be able to agree to talk through exam stress and not be able to agree, alone, to something more complex, so the question is asked again when the service changes. It would be unusual for a child under 12 to meet the test, and a court can override a mature minor's decision.
If your teenager does not meet it, consent comes from a parent or guardian, and the psychologist still explains things to them and looks for their agreement. Either way the aim is not to work around you: good practice is to involve parents unless there is a compelling reason not to.
If you and the other parent are separated, each of you keeps parental responsibility unless a court order says otherwise. With no orders, a psychologist can rely on one parent's consent. Where orders require major long-term decisions to be made jointly, the guidance is that both parents' consent is needed, except in urgent situations involving risk. Expect to be asked whether there are orders, and for a copy of the relevant part.
What will I be told?
That should be settled out loud at the start, with you and your teenager both in the room. Professional guidelines say the limits of confidentiality are to be made clear at the outset to everyone involved, parents included.
The legal position turns on capacity. If your teenager can consent for themselves, their agreement may be needed before you can see their file, and any sessions the psychologist has with you should fit what your teenager has agreed to. If they cannot, and no court order restricts it, both parents generally have a legal right to their child's information, session notes included, though the psychologist will also weigh things like family violence and risk of harm before releasing it.
Between everything and nothing there is a lot of room. With your teenager's agreement, the psychologist can:
- give you a general account of what they are working on, without the detail;
- bring you into a session, or sit alongside while your teenager tells you something themselves;
- talk to you privately about a particular matter your teenager wants you to know.
Even if your teenager says no to all of that, the psychologist can still suggest general things to do at home, worded so that they neither reveal what was said nor give you a false picture.
Three things often surprise parents. If you ring with information and ask that your teenager not be told you called, the psychologist may tell them anyway, where that is appropriate and safe. Notes from any session you have with the psychologist go on your teenager's file, not a separate one of yours. And the psychologist is your teenager's: if you want individual help yourself, you would be referred to someone else, because treating two members of one family can create a conflict of interest.
When will the psychologist tell me, whatever my teenager wants?
When staying quiet would leave your teenager, or someone else, at risk of harm. A young person's confidentiality holds only for as long as keeping it does not put them at risk from themselves or others. This is why a psychologist should not promise a teenager total secrecy. It cannot be kept, and a young person who sees that promise broken can find it hard to trust a professional again.
Where the line falls is a judgement, not a formula. In Australian studies, most psychologists said they would break confidentiality over something like a suicide attempt, and most said they would keep it over something like occasional binge drinking. In between, they weighed how harmful the behaviour was and what telling would do to the working relationship. So take a 15-year-old who mentions that he got drunk at a party last month: his parents would probably not hear that from the psychologist. If the same boy says he has been planning to end his life, they would.
How you hear matters too. The recommended approach is to tell the young person first that telling you is being considered, explain why, and give them the chance to tell you themselves. You may well hear it from your own child, with the psychologist in the room.
Child protection is separate, and it overrides confidentiality however mature the young person is. In Victoria, a psychologist who believes on reasonable grounds that a child has suffered or is likely to suffer significant harm from physical injury or sexual abuse, and that the parents have not protected or are unlikely to protect them, must report it to child protection. Other states and territories set the duty differently.
Expect the psychologist to ask your teenager directly about thoughts of harming themselves. Asking does not make a young person more likely to act on such thoughts, and the greater risk lies in not asking. If you are worried about your teenager's safety, see your GP, and in an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.
Why does some privacy help?
Because a teenager who expects every word to be carried home will edit what they say, and therapy with a young person is of limited use unless they are engaged in it.
Parents of adolescents are also often unaware of how their child is feeling. That is no criticism. It is the reason standard screening questionnaires come in a version the young person fills in themselves from about 11, alongside the parent and teacher versions, and the reason adolescents should always be offered time alone with the psychologist. Privacy is not the point of the exercise. It is a condition for hearing what is going on.
What should I ask at the first appointment?
- What will I be told as a matter of routine, and how often?
- What would you tell me without my teenager's agreement, and how would you go about it?
- Who can see the notes?
- If I am worried about something at home, how do I pass it on, and will my teenager know I did?
- If we are separated: does the other parent need to consent, and will we both get the same information?
Ask them with your teenager listening. Being shut out and being told everything are not the only two options, and the arrangement that holds up is one your teenager heard being agreed. Then, if the psychologist does have to come to you one day, it is something your child already knew could happen.
References
- Code of conduct for psychologists. Psychology Board of Australia
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). Federal Register of Legislation
- Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic). Victorian Legislation
- A Multidisciplinary Handbook of Child and Adolescent Mental Health for Front-line Professionals (3rd ed.). Dogra, Parkin, Warner-Gale and Frake, Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2017
Make an appointment
Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.