Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

What is a normal reaction to trauma, and when is it PTSD?

Most people do not develop PTSD after a traumatic event. What early reactions look like, what keeps some people stuck, and what therapy involves.

Published

Picture someone ten days after another car ran a red light and hit the side of theirs. Nobody was badly hurt. But they wake at three in the morning hearing the impact, flinch when a truck brakes behind them, and now drive the long way to work to miss that intersection. Their partner is wondering whether this is post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

At ten days it cannot be. PTSD is only diagnosed once the difficulties have lasted more than a month. A different fact matters more at this stage. According to the Australian PTSD guidelines, most people who go through a traumatic event do not go on to develop PTSD.

What the first days and weeks can look like

After an event involving a real threat to life, serious injury or sexual violence, strong early reactions can be a passing stress response that settles within the month. The event may replay uninvited or turn up in dreams. People steer away from the place or the subject, sleep badly, startle easily, or feel detached, as if things are not quite real. Others are oddly calm or numb while it is happening, which is a recognised response too.

What the guidelines suggest for this period is plainer than most people expect: information, emotional support and practical help, in preference to psychological debriefing, where a person is taken back through the event and their reactions in detail soon afterwards. Nobody has to talk it all through in the first week.

That does not mean waiting is always right. For adults who do have post-traumatic stress symptoms in the first three months, the guidelines suggest offering trauma-focused therapy in preference to doing nothing.

What makes post-traumatic stress different

Three things: the event, the pattern, and time.

In the diagnostic sense, trauma means exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury or sexual violence, whether it happened to you, you witnessed it, it happened to someone close to you, or you meet its details repeatedly through your work, as first responders do. A separation or a redundancy can be devastating, but is not a traumatic event in this sense. Lasting distress after one is real, and is assessed in its own right.

The pattern is four kinds of change together. The event keeps coming back uninvited, in memories that are vivid and physical, which is different from brooding over it. The person avoids reminders, both the places and the thoughts. Mood and beliefs shift: blame, feeling cut off from people, losing interest in things. And the body stays on guard, with poor sleep, jumpiness and irritability.

Then time. The difficulties have lasted more than a month and get in the way of work, relationships or ordinary life. The DSM-5-TR diagnostic manual reports that about half of adults with PTSD recover completely within three months, while some still have symptoms more than a year later.

That is a description, not a checklist. Depression, anxiety and grief can follow a terrible event too and can look similar, and telling them apart takes a careful interview. Post-traumatic stress can also go unrecognised, because people often come in about sleep, anger, a relationship or headaches and may not mention the event at all.

Why avoidance keeps it going

Avoidance works, in the short run. Skip the intersection, change the subject, have a few drinks to get to sleep, and the anxiety drops. But fear tends to fade through repeated contact with the things that set it off, and avoidance removes that contact, so the person never finds out that the intersection, the memory or the conversation can be borne.

The same avoidance makes people reluctant to seek help, and to speak about the event once they have. Not wanting to talk about it is often part of the condition, not a sign that therapy is wrong for you.

Stuck points, and what therapy involves week to week

For adults with PTSD, the Australian guidelines recommend several trauma-focused therapies: cognitive processing therapy (CPT), trauma-focused cognitive therapy, prolonged exposure, and eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing (EMDR). A 2024 review by the Australian Psychological Society found its highest level of evidence, meaning systematic reviews of randomised trials, for trauma-focused cognitive behaviour therapies and for EMDR in adults with PTSD. That is not a promise about any one person. The same review notes that, in complex PTSD, treatment worked less well for people whose trauma happened in childhood.

CPT starts from the idea that after a traumatic event, people draw conclusions about why it happened and what it means, and some of those conclusions keep them from recovering. CPT calls them stuck points. Imagine the driver from the intersection, four months on, still saying 'I should have braked sooner', although the other car ran the light. Or 'you can't trust anyone on the road', which is how the long way to work became the only way.

CPT usually runs for about twelve sessions, sometimes fewer or more. After an introduction to PTSD and the therapy, an early task is to write an impact statement about what the event has meant and how it has affected you, with attention to guilt and self-blame. You then learn to name what you feel and to trace the links between an event, a thought and a feeling. The psychologist does not argue with a stuck point. They ask questions about it (what did you know at that moment, what could anyone have done) and teach you, with worksheets, to put the same questions to yourself. The last five sessions take up areas that trauma commonly disrupts: safety, trust, power and control, esteem and intimacy.

In prolonged exposure, by contrast, you describe the memory aloud in the present tense, usually for 30 to 45 minutes, listen to a recording between sessions, and gradually return to the situations you have been avoiding. In EMDR you recall the event while following eye movements or another kind of side-to-side stimulation. Because the guidelines recommend all of these, the choice is made with you. For children and teenagers, they recommend trauma-focused cognitive behaviour therapy, including with a parent or carer involved.

Do you have to describe everything that happened?

Not at the beginning. The guidelines say a brief outline is enough in the first sessions, and that pressing for detail early can be distressing and can work against the therapy.

After that it depends on the therapy. Prolonged exposure involves telling it in detail. CPT is mainly about meaning, and a version that adds a detailed written account exists as an alternative. For people who hear what trauma-focused therapy involves and decide against it, the guidelines suggest other options, including present-centred therapy, which works on current problems instead of the event. An informed no is respected.

The honest caveat is that the guidelines recommend the trauma-focused therapies first, and treatment is likely to mean going over the event more closely. A psychologist will usually suggest approaching it gradually, at a pace you agree to.

Post-traumatic stress often comes with depression or problems with alcohol, and it is associated with suicidal thoughts, so a psychologist will ask about all three as routine. See your GP if you are leaning on alcohol to sleep, or to discuss medication, which the guidelines suggest mainly where psychological therapy is not available, not wanted or has not helped enough. In an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.

Two things are worth knowing, at different moments. Early on, the odds favour things settling, and what helps is ordinary. Later, if they have not settled, being stuck has a shape that can be described: often a habit of avoidance and a handful of conclusions drawn in the worst minute of someone's life. Both can be looked at closely, and that is where therapy starts.

References

  1. Australian Guidelines for the Prevention and Treatment of Acute Stress Disorder, Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Complex PTSD. Phoenix Australia, 2020 (with later updates)
  2. Evidence-based Psychological Interventions in the Treatment of Mental Disorders: A Literature Review (5th ed.). Australian Psychological Society, 2024
  3. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR). American Psychiatric Association, 2022
  4. Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders: A Step-by-Step Treatment Manual (6th ed.), chapter 2. Barlow (ed.), Guilford Press, 2021

Make an appointment

Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.

Back to blog