Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

A parent's memory or mood has changed. What could it mean?

What normally changes with age, how depression and delirium can be mistaken for dementia, why the GP comes first, and what an assessment adds.

Published

Suppose your father is 79 and has always done his own tax. On Tuesday he rings to ask what day you are coming for lunch, although you told him on Monday. He has also stopped going to bowls, and when you ask why, he says he can't be bothered. Driving home, you wonder whether this is just age or the start of something else.

Nobody can answer that from a description, and this article will not try. It sets out how clinicians think the question through, so you know what to tell the GP and which changes should not wait. The same applies if the change you have noticed is in yourself.

What usually changes with age, and what usually doesn't

Some slowing is ordinary. The Seattle Longitudinal Study found that most intellectual abilities keep rising into middle adulthood, hold steady into the fifties or sixties, and then decline gradually. Speed falls with age. So does working memory, the ability to hold something in mind while working on it. The important word is "gradually". A marked drop over a short period is not usually explained by ageing.

Two things that many people expect to worsen generally do not. One is mood. Research finds that negative feelings become less frequent at least until about 60, and positive feelings stay steady or dip only slightly afterwards, so lasting low mood should not be put down to age. The other is personality, which does not usually deteriorate with age, so a marked change in character should be assessed.

Nor is a smaller social circle a symptom in itself. Many older people choose fewer, closer friends and are content.

The first question is how fast it happened

A change that arrives over hours or a few days is a medical problem until a doctor says otherwise. Delirium is a disturbance of attention and awareness that develops quickly and tends to come and go during the day, often worse in the evening and at night. The person may lose the thread of a conversation, be muddled about where they are, see things that are not there, or become very agitated. There is also a quiet form, in which the person is drowsy and sluggish, and it often goes unrecognised in older people, including in hospitals.

Delirium has a physical cause: an illness, a substance or a medicine. In older adults the most frequent cause is a reaction to a medicine or a combination of medicines. The causes are often treatable, but left untreated they can lead to permanent brain damage or death. Delirium is frequently mistaken for dementia, and a person who already has dementia can develop it too.

A sudden change in an older person's thinking, alertness or behaviour needs urgent medical attention. Ring the GP that day. In an emergency, call 000.

Depression can look like a memory problem

Depression can produce slowed thinking, low motivation and a loss of interest in things the person used to enjoy. That picture can resemble dementia, and depression is the most common cause of a dementia-like impairment that proves reversible.

One finding surprises most families. In older adults, complaints about failing memory go with depression more than with measured memory performance, and most depressed older people show little or no measurable loss on testing. So a parent who is distressed about their memory has not, by that alone, shown a sign of dementia. Nor does it rule dementia out, which is why memory has to be measured.

The two tend to look different on testing. Consistent difficulty with memory and planning is typical of Alzheimer's disease, while results in depression are more uneven. They also occur together. Depression is common early in Alzheimer's disease, and treating it often improves how a person with dementia manages. Sometimes the question is settled only by treating the mood and observing over time.

If an older person says things like "I'm no use to anyone", ask them directly whether they have thought about ending their life. A recent visit to the GP does not mean anyone has asked. In an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.

What dementia means, in broad terms

Dementia is a pattern that many different illnesses can cause, not a single disease. It is a lasting decline from the person's own earlier level, usually in several areas of thinking. With causes such as Alzheimer's disease it typically comes on slowly and progresses gradually. Not every dementia starts with memory. Some begin with changes in behaviour, empathy or language, and can at first be taken for a mood or personality problem.

The dividing line clinicians use is independence. A person with mild cognitive impairment still pays the bills and manages their tablets, perhaps with more effort, lists and reminders. In dementia they need someone's help with those tasks. Mild cognitive impairment signals a raised risk and is not a verdict. Many people with it develop dementia within five years, and some return to normal functioning.

Why the GP comes first

Before poor memory is read as dementia, a doctor needs to look for causes that can be treated, including vitamin B12 deficiency, an underactive thyroid, the effects of medicines and long-term heavy drinking. A small proportion of people who appear to have dementia turn out to have a reversible condition. A larger group have a treatable problem that is making things worse, so the review is worth having even when dementia is present.

With your parent's agreement, go along and take:

  • a rough timeline of when you first noticed a change, and whether it arrived suddenly or crept in
  • whether they are much the same every day or clearly better and worse at different times
  • examples of things they once managed and now struggle with, such as bills, tablets or following a television plot
  • a list of every medicine they take, noting anything started recently
  • their glasses and hearing aids, in working order, because poor hearing or eyesight can pass for confusion

What a psychologist's assessment adds

A GP may begin with a brief screening test. Its single score is not a sound basis for diagnosing dementia or ruling it out. Brief screens can miss a modest decline in someone who started from a high level, and can suggest impairment that is not there in someone with little schooling or someone tested outside their first language.

A fuller cognitive assessment uses a set of standardised tasks covering attention, memory and new learning, language, planning, and visual and spatial skills. Results are compared with people of the same age, so that ordinary ageing is not mistaken for decline, and the pattern across many tasks is stronger evidence than any single number. Mood is assessed separately. A family member is usually asked how the person managed years ago, because a low score in someone who has always found such tasks hard is not evidence of decline.

Done properly, it is unhurried: a quiet, well-lit room, glasses on, hearing aids in, breaks, and often two or more shorter sessions, because rushing and fatigue make mild problems look worse than they are. Where English is not the person's strongest language, a professional interpreter is used.

Sometimes the honest result is "not clear yet". The boundary between normal ageing and mild impairment is not sharp, and ambiguous findings become a baseline to compare against later. Where low mood is part of the picture, therapy can begin before every other question is settled.

An assessment describes how a person is thinking. It does not decide what they are allowed to choose. Victorian guardianship law presumes that a person has capacity unless there is evidence otherwise, and capacity is judged one decision at a time, not by diagnosis. Do all of this with your parent, not around them.

References

  1. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR). American Psychiatric Association, 2022
  2. Mental Disorders in Older Adults: Fundamentals of Assessment and Treatment (2nd ed.). Zarit and Zarit, Guilford Press, 2007
  3. Rowland Universal Dementia Assessment Scale (RUDAS): administration and scoring guide. Dementia Australia

Make an appointment

Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.

Back to blog