Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

Does my child have a learning disorder? How assessment works

What is tested in an assessment for dyslexia or another specific learning disorder, why one score is not enough, and how schools use the report.

Published

The sentence often comes from a teacher, a few minutes into a parent interview: "She's bright, but she can't get it on paper." Many parents who hear it already know. Picture a nine-year-old who can explain at the dinner table, in detail, how a volcano works, and who then hands in three laboured lines on the same topic.

That mismatch between what a child understands and what they can read, write or calculate is a recognised pattern. When it meets certain conditions it has a formal name, specific learning disorder, with the affected area stated: reading, written expression or mathematics. When reading is the affected area, schools and families often call it dyslexia. This is what an assessment for it involves, and why a careful one needs more than a single test.

What do parents usually notice first?

Often it is not a mark on a school report. It is a gap. One child reads aloud well enough but cannot organise a paragraph. Another takes twice as long as classmates to copy from the whiteboard. Another is still well behind in reading after a year in the small group that was meant to help.

Sometimes the first thing noticed looks like poor concentration. A child with a learning disorder can seem inattentive out of frustration, yet listen closely when the task does not depend on the weak skill, such as being read a story when reading is the problem. Some parents arrive wondering about ADHD for this reason, and telling the two apart is part of the work.

And sometimes very little shows on paper. A child who works unusually hard, has found workarounds, or gets a lot of help at home can keep results respectable while the underlying skill stays weak.

Is "bright but can't get it on paper" a real pattern?

Yes, in the sense that it describes something an assessment can measure: reasoning that is solid or strong, alongside one academic skill that is well behind. Slow, effortful written work in a child with strong verbal ability raises the possibility of a learning disorder in written expression, and that possibility deserves proper testing.

It is not proof, though. Children fall behind for many reasons, and not every child with low results has a learning disorder. Hearing or eyesight that has never been checked, a patchy start to schooling, still learning English, worry, and attention difficulties can all produce a similar picture. The pattern is a reason to assess, not a reason to assume. "She's bright, she'll catch up" is as untested as any label.

What is tested?

Four kinds of information are gathered, and the conclusion depends on how they fit together.

  1. Ability. A cognitive test (for ages 6 to 16, usually the WISC-V) looks at reasoning with words, reasoning with shapes and patterns, working memory and processing speed. The main tasks take a little over an hour on average. Extra tasks can be added that look at how quickly a child names familiar things and how well they link visual symbols with spoken words, both of which are associated with reading, writing and maths.
  2. Achievement. A separate test, given one-to-one, measures reading, writing and maths directly, along with listening and speaking. One such test, the WIAT-III, has Australian and New Zealand norms for ages 4 to 19. It tests the foundation skills that school depends on, not any particular curriculum. It can compare a child with others the same age or in the same year level, which matters if a child has repeated a year.
  3. History. When the difficulty was first noticed, early development, the languages spoken at home, any interruptions to schooling, and what you see at home. You will also be asked whether hearing and vision have been tested. If not, arrange that through your GP.
  4. School information. The teacher's account of what happens in class, how reading or maths has been taught, what extra help has been given and for how long, and any earlier assessment reports.

If your child was assessed elsewhere in the past year or so, mention it before booking. Repeating the same cognitive test too soon can lift scores through familiarity alone, and the earlier results may still be current.

Why is one gap between two scores not enough?

The traditional check for a learning disorder was a subtraction: ability score well above reading score. That comparison is still made, but the technical manual for the children's ability test says it cannot be the sole marker, for three reasons.

  • A gap has many possible causes. Children underachieve for reasons that are unrelated to a learning disorder.
  • A learning disorder can exist with no gap. Effort, coping strategies and support can hold the achievement score up. From the other side, learning disorders tend to come with lower working memory and processing speed, which pull the overall IQ down and can hide the difference.
  • Scores are estimates. Each has a margin of error. A gap has to be larger than chance would produce, and also uncommon among children generally, before it means much.

So a second analysis is run beside the first. It asks whether there is a particular weakness in thinking skills that makes sense of the academic weakness, with clear strengths elsewhere. Even then, the manual advises against identifying a learning disorder from any single analysis.

The diagnostic criteria ask for more again. The skill has to be substantially below what is expected for the child's age, confirmed by both a standardised test and a full clinical assessment. Other explanations have to be ruled out: intellectual disability, uncorrected vision or hearing problems, other mental or neurological conditions, adversity in the child's life, limited English, and inadequate teaching.

How long must the difficulty have lasted?

At least six months, despite help aimed at that particular difficulty. This is written into the diagnostic criteria, and it is why the psychologist asks the school what support has been provided and for how long.

Two practical things follow. If targeted help has not been tried yet, an assessment can still describe your child's skills and what to do next, but the diagnosis itself may have to wait. And extra reading or maths support does not need to wait for an assessment. How a child responds to that support is part of the evidence.

What is the report used for at school?

A school usually wants to know two things: why this child is not learning the skill, and what will help. A useful report answers both in language a teacher can act on. It explains what the results mean for classroom work, describes strengths as well as difficulties, and makes recommendations a school can realistically carry out. Schools also use reports to support applications for extra help.

Scores are given as ranges with percentiles and explained in words, because a percentile is easily mistaken for a percentage of correct answers.

The report goes to the school only if you consent in writing and name the school. The school receives the interpreted report, not raw scores or test booklets. And because school files are not held as tightly as a clinic's, family matters that are not the school's business are left out.

No single score in the report should be used alone to grant or refuse support, and the guidelines psychologists work under say so directly. If the conclusion is that the difficulty is not a learning disorder, the report should still say what was found and what your child needs.

By the end, "bright but can't get it on paper" should have been replaced by something more exact: which skill, how far behind, for how long, despite what help, and what to try next.

References

  1. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR). American Psychiatric Association, 2022
  2. Wechsler Individual Achievement Test, Third Edition: Australian and New Zealand Standardised Edition (WIAT-III A&NZ). Pearson Clinical Assessment, 2016
  3. Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Fifth Edition: Australian and New Zealand Standardised Edition (WISC-V A&NZ). Pearson Clinical Assessment, 2016

Book an assessment

Choose a time online, or ask us a question first.

Book an assessment

Back to blog