How to read a psychological assessment report
The parts of an assessment report, what standard scores, percentiles and confidence intervals mean, and what to ask at the feedback session.
Published
"Is 85 a pass?" It is one of the first things parents ask when an assessment report arrives, and a fair question about a document that holds a dozen scores and no marks out of anything.
There is no pass mark. The scores say where a person's performance sat, on one day, against other people of the same age. The report's job is to say what that means for this particular child or adult, and what should happen next. Here is how to read one.
Read it in this order
Layouts differ, but most reports have the same parts.
- The referral question. What the assessment was meant to answer. A report is supposed to be organised around this, and its conclusions should answer each question, or say plainly that one could not be answered.
- Background and sources. Who supplied information: you, a teacher, a GP, earlier reports. Things the psychologist was only told should be attributed to whoever said them, not stated as fact.
- Observations. How the person went about the tasks, and anything that may have affected the results, such as tiredness on the day or a test given in a non-standard way (extra time on a timed task, for example).
- Results. The scores, usually in tables.
- Summary and interpretation. What the results mean when put together with everything else, strengths included.
- Recommendations. What should happen next.
It is fine to read the question first and the summary second. The summary is written on the assumption that some readers will read nothing else, and it should contain nothing that is not backed up in the body. If it says something you cannot find support for further up, ask.
What the three kinds of number mean
Standard scores. On the Wechsler tests (the WISC for children, the WAIS for adults) the main scores are scaled so that the average for the person's age is 100. Each range has a label: 90 to 109 is Average, 80 to 89 Low Average, 110 to 119 High Average, and so on. So 85 is neither a pass nor a fail. It sits in the Low Average range. Older reports, and some adult ones, call 70 to 79 "Borderline"; current children's reports say "Very Low". The individual tasks within a test use a smaller scale on which 10 is average.
Percentiles. A percentile says how many people out of a hundred of the same age scored lower. It is easily mistaken for the percentage of questions answered correctly, which it is not. A score at the 50th percentile is exactly average, not half marks.
Confidence intervals. Every test score is an estimate with some error in it. The confidence interval is the range within which the person's true score probably lies, and a report should give it beside each main score.
A worked example
Take a made-up eleven-year-old whose teacher says she follows class discussion easily but loses track of instructions with several steps. Her invented results include:
- Verbal Comprehension: 120, 91st percentile, Very High
- Working Memory: 84 (95 per cent confidence interval 78 to 91), 14th percentile, Low Average
In plain words: on tasks of reasoning with words, she scored higher than 91 in 100 children her age. On tasks of holding information in mind for a short time and working with it, she scored higher than about 14 in 100. The interval says her true working memory score probably lies somewhere between 78 and 91, which runs from Very Low into Average, so 84 should not be treated as exact.
Two more things matter. Is the gap between the scores bigger than measurement error could produce, and how common is a gap that size? Test manuals answer both, and a gap can be real and still quite ordinary. And is a score low compared with other people, or only compared with the person's own other scores? A personal low point that is still in the average range may cause no trouble in daily life.
Why the interpretation matters more than the numbers
The numbers in the example describe test performance. The useful sentence is the one that connects them to the classroom: she understands what is said, and she loses the later steps of a long instruction. A good report uses results to describe the person. A weaker one describes the tests and leaves the joining up to you.
Signs that the thinking has been done:
- Conclusions rest on more than one piece of evidence (scores, history, observation, what teachers or family report), never on a single score.
- You can tell which sentences are facts, such as a score, and which are the psychologist's interpretation.
- Firm findings are stated plainly, and doubt is expressed only where there is real doubt.
- The paragraphs are recognisably about this person. Scoring software can generate standard interpretive text, but it cannot take a person's circumstances into account, and the psychologist remains responsible for every word.
Professional guidelines add that a single test score is not an appropriate reason to grant or withdraw access to a service.
What good recommendations look like
They follow from the findings and answer the question the assessment started with. They are realistic for the person and family who have to carry them out. They are specific enough for a teacher, GP or employer to act on. Where it is warranted, they say when a follow-up assessment should happen.
Who can see the report, and who decides
In most cases, you decide. Unless the law requires disclosure, results go only to the people named in your written consent. For a child, a parent or guardian usually gives that consent, and a school receives the report only if it has been named. With teenagers, psychologists take the young person's maturity and capacity to understand into account.
Schools hold records under looser confidentiality than a private practice does, and a full report may include family history the school has no need for. You can ask for a separate school version that covers learning and what helps in class. A sound working rule is to assume that anyone entitled to read a report will read it.
Two exceptions. Test questions and record forms are not handed over, to protect the integrity of the tests. And when an insurer or employer arranges the assessment, the psychologist should explain at the outset who receives the report and whether you will get feedback.
You can ask for factual errors to be corrected. A psychologist should not change a finding because a reader disagrees with it, though your view can be recorded.
What the feedback session is for
A report read without explanation is easy to misread, IQ scores and diagnoses especially. So the psychologist who did the assessment is responsible for explaining it, in everyday language, and should tell you when to expect both the feedback and the written report.
Expect three or four main findings, each tied to examples you will recognise, not a tour of every score. Expect to be asked whether the picture fits. If it does not, say so in the room. You can bring a support person. Questions worth taking with you:
- Which of our original questions has this answered, and which has it not?
- Which findings are you most sure of, and which least?
- Did anything on the day affect the scores?
- What should we do first, and when, if ever, should the assessment be repeated?
- Who will receive the report, and can there be a separate version for the school?
A report has done its job if, a month later, you can say in two or three sentences what it found and what is being done differently because of it. If you cannot, go back and ask. Explaining it is part of the work.
References
- Code of conduct for psychologists. Psychology Board of Australia
- Essentials of Assessment Report Writing (2nd ed.). Schneider, Lichtenberger, Mather and Kaufman, Wiley, 2018
- Handbook of Psychological Assessment (6th ed.). Groth-Marnat and Wright, Wiley, 2016
Book an assessment
Choose a time online, or ask us a question first.
Book an assessment