Hearing voices does not always mean psychosis
Hearing a voice or sound that others do not is more common than most people think. Where it occurs, what clinicians look at, and why to see a GP.
Published
Take a woman three weeks after her husband's funeral. She is rinsing a cup at the kitchen sink when she hears him say her name from the next room, in his ordinary voice, as clearly as he ever said it. The room is empty. She tells no one, because she knows what people think hearing voices means.
What people think it means is often wrong. Hearing a voice or a sound that nobody else hears is frightening largely because of its reputation. The experience turns up in many more circumstances than the one people fear, and several of them are within the range of ordinary human experience.
A voice alone is not a diagnosis
Clinicians call a perception with no outside source a hallucination. Voices are the kind of hallucination most associated with schizophrenia, which is where the reputation comes from.
Researchers who study voice-hearing have been questioning that association for some years. One review describes voices as a frequently occurring experience in the general population. A 2018 paper by an international group of researchers argues that hearing voices is "not necessarily a hallmark of psychotic disorder". Its authors point out that many people who seek help for persistent voices have no other sign of psychosis, keep a firm sense of what is real, and never go on to develop schizophrenia.
Psychosis is a wider change than hearing something. A diagnosis of schizophrenia, for example, requires more than one kind of symptom, lasting over months, together with a marked falling away from the person's usual life. One experience, however vivid, does not amount to that.
Where these experiences turn up
On the edge of sleep
Hearing or seeing something while falling asleep, or just as you wake, is regarded as within the range of normal experience.
After a death, and within faith and culture
In many cultures it is common, and even expected, for a bereaved person to hear, see or sense the person who has died, without any lasting harm. In some religious traditions, hearing the voice of God is a normal part of faith.
For many Aboriginal people, hearing the voices of relatives is a familiar experience with spiritual meaning, and Australian guidance for health workers warns against mistaking it for illness.
Under severe stress and after trauma
After a traumatic event, flashbacks can have the quality of a hallucination: the person hears or sees part of what happened as if it were happening now. These are tied to the event and come without the other features of psychosis. The 2018 paper lists post-traumatic stress among the causes of voices in people who do not have a psychotic disorder. Voices can also occur during an episode of severe depression, where they are assessed and treated as part of the mood problem.
With illness, medicines, alcohol and other drugs
Some causes are physical. Hearing loss, sleep disorders, epilepsy, and some hormonal and autoimmune conditions have all been linked with experiences of this kind. So can intoxication with, or withdrawal from, alcohol and other drugs, and so can some medicines.
When an older person develops psychotic symptoms for the first time, an estimated 60 per cent have a medical cause. A sudden change over hours or days, with confusion and wandering attention, may be delirium. Delirium is caused by an illness, a drug or a medicine. It is often mistaken for dementia or a psychiatric problem, and it needs urgent medical attention.
In childhood
What a child reports has to be told apart from imaginative play. Simple hallucinations in children do not predict a psychotic illness, and schizophrenia before adolescence is rare. If a child is distressed by what they hear or see, or it keeps happening, it is still worth telling the GP.
Why a stressed brain may hear what is not there
Hearing is not a recording. One account of perception, called predictive coding, holds that the brain is continually predicting what it is about to hear and checking the prediction against what arrives at the ear. Usually the incoming sound corrects the guess. The proposal is that, now and then, a strong expectation wins, and the person hears what the brain predicted instead of what was there.
Stress seems to tilt the balance. In one experiment, healthy volunteers listened for speech buried in white noise. Under stress, the more anxious among them became readier to report speech when none had been played. When the context led people to expect a word, they were better at detecting it when it was really there, and also more inclined to report it when it was not.
One way to read this is that a brain on alert errs towards the false alarm, because hearing a threat that is not there costs less than missing one that is. This is a theory, and it does not explain every voice. It does make some sense of the woman at the sink. After forty years, the expectation of that voice in that house is a well-worn path.
What a clinician looks at
No blood test or scan answers the question. An assessment is a careful conversation, and no single experience is read by itself. The kind of experience is treated as a reason to look further and never as a verdict.
The clinician asks when it happens, how long it has been going on and what the voice or sound is like. They ask what else has changed in sleep, mood, thinking and daily life, what medicines, alcohol or other drugs are involved, and what has happened recently. They ask what the person makes of it, and what it means in their family, faith and culture.
Broadly, the experiences that most need assessment are those that persist or increase, that are hostile or tell the person to do things, that come with other changes (withdrawing from friends, work or study falling away, beliefs that others find strange and that will not shift), or that begin suddenly alongside confusion or physical illness.
Those answers count together, which is why this article offers no list to tick off. The same experience can be unremarkable in one person and important in another. Working out which takes someone who can ask about the whole picture. It is not a job to do alone at two in the morning.
Why see a GP, and when it is urgent
Anyone who is worried about hearing things should tell their GP. A GP can look for physical causes, review medicines, and arrange a mental health assessment where one is needed. If a psychotic illness is developing, early assessment matters, and public mental health services have teams set up for early psychosis. A private psychology practice is not an acute service, and a psychologist who sees signs of psychosis will arrange that assessment before anything else.
Where voices are distressing and no psychotic illness is found, the 2018 paper suggests that people may benefit from approaches such as building ways of coping and trauma-focused therapy. Psychological work with voices does not set out to argue about whether they are real. It starts from understanding the experience and the distress it causes.
Some situations should not wait. If a voice is telling you, or someone you care about, to harm yourself or anyone else, or if a person has become suddenly confused, get help straight away. In an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.
The woman at the sink is afraid of one question: whether she is losing her mind. A more useful question is what is going on around the experience, and that one has many ordinary answers. Finding out which applies starts with saying it aloud to someone whose job is to ask what comes next.
References
- Auditory hallucinations, not necessarily a hallmark of psychotic disorder. Waters, Blom, Jardri, Hugdahl and Sommer, Psychological Medicine, 2018, 48, 529-536
- Auditory verbal hallucinations: neuroimaging and treatment. Bohlken, Hugdahl and Sommer, Psychological Medicine, 2017, 47, 199-208
- The effect of psychological stress and expectation on auditory perception: a signal detection analysis. Hoskin, Hunter and Woodruff, British Journal of Psychology, 2014, 105, 524-546
- Auditory hallucinations: expectation-perception model. Nazimek, Hunter and Woodruff, Medical Hypotheses, 2012, 78, 802-810
- Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR). American Psychiatric Association, 2022
- Working Together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Mental Health and Wellbeing Principles and Practice (2nd ed.). Dudgeon, Milroy and Walker (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, 2014
Make an appointment
Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.