Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

Your first session with a psychologist, and why all the questions

What a psychologist explains at the start of a first session, why each kind of question is asked, and how the answers become a plan you agree on.

Published

At some point in a first session with a psychologist there is a good chance you will be asked how much coffee you drink. You may have come about panic attacks, or a marriage, or a fourteen-year-old who has stopped going to school, and the question will seem to come from nowhere.

It doesn't. Nearly every question in a first session has a job to do, and knowing the jobs makes the whole thing a good deal less strange.

Before any questions, the ground rules

The session should open with the psychologist explaining, in plain language, what their role is, what the service involves, how your information will be used and stored, what is confidential and where confidentiality stops, and what it costs. If someone else is paying or expects a report (an insurer, say), you should be told from the outset what will go to them. You can ask questions, take time to decide, decline to talk about anything you would rather not, and withdraw your consent later. Expect to be asked to say what you have understood, because a signature on a form sent in advance does not replace the conversation. None of this is a courtesy. Most of it is set out in the Psychology Board of Australia's Code of conduct.

It starts with your version

The first real question is usually wide open: what brings you here, or how you came to be referred. An open question lets you tell it your way, and how a person tells their story (where they begin, how they organise it, where they hesitate) is information no form collects.

From there the questions narrow. You may be asked to describe a typical day, and then the last time the problem happened, step by step, as if you were watching a film of it. One specific episode shows more than a summary of what usually happens. Direct questions come later, to fill the gaps. The order matters too: easier subjects first, sensitive ones once you have had a chance to settle, and a gentler question after a hard one.

You are unlikely to be asked 'why did you do that'. 'How did it come about that...' invites a description. 'Why' tends to invite a defence.

Why the questions go where they do

  • Health, sleep, appetite and medication. Thyroid and heart conditions, head injuries and neurological conditions can all show up as low mood, anxiety or poor concentration. If something points that way, the psychologist should raise it with you and suggest a check with your GP before putting it down to stress.
  • Coffee, cigarettes, alcohol and other drugs. Everyone is asked, whatever they came about. It usually starts with caffeine because that is the easy end of the subject.
  • Earlier treatment. What helped, what did not, and how it ended.
  • Family, relationships, work and school. These give the problem its context, show who is in your corner, and bring out any family history of similar difficulties.
  • Thoughts of suicide or of harming someone, and any experience of abuse. These are asked of every client, not because of anything you said. Some people at serious risk are too embarrassed or too low to raise it themselves, and asking about suicide does not put the idea in anyone's mind. (In an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.)
  • What is going well. Strengths and supports are assessed alongside problems, because they are usually what therapy builds on.

For a very young child, most of this comes from the parents, with the child in the room. A teenager should always be offered time alone with the psychologist. For an older relative, someone who knows them well is often asked for their account, with the person's permission.

There is a limit worth being straight about. What any of us remembers is a reconstruction, least reliable for family conflict and for when symptoms began. Psychologists have a known weakness too: forming an early impression and then steering towards whatever confirms it. So what a first interview produces is treated as a working hypothesis, to be checked as more comes in.

From answers to a working explanation

A diagnosis, where there is one, names the problem. A formulation explains it: a provisional account of why this person has this difficulty now. It usually covers what the problem looks like day to day, what set it off, what keeps it going, what made the person vulnerable to it, and what they have going for them.

Take a hypothetical man referred for 'low mood' who has stopped going to his cricket club since he was made redundant. The label says little. A formulation would ask what the redundancy meant to him (perhaps 'I'm no use to anyone now'), notice that staying home means he never finds out whether his friends think any less of him, and count the years he spent running the club's roster as something to build on. Each part points to a different piece of the plan, which is why two people with the same diagnosis can need different things.

A formulation is built with you, in ordinary words, and your view of whether it is accurate counts. It is rarely finished in one session. It is added to in layers, tested against what happens, and revised when it turns out to be wrong.

Agreeing on goals, and why the relationship matters

Goals are agreed, not handed down. If you say you want to feel less anxious, expect to be asked what you would want to feel instead, and what you would be doing, where, and how often, if things were better. Usually one goal is chosen to start with and broken into steps, easiest first. Progress is then measured from a starting point, with the same measures each time, partly because psychologists going on impression alone tend to overestimate how much their clients have improved.

Agreement on goals is also one third of what researchers call the working alliance. The other two parts are agreement on how you will work together and a bond of trust. Textbooks that review this research describe the quality of the alliance as one of the strongest and most consistent predictors of how therapy turns out, across different kinds of therapy, including therapy by phone or online.

The practical upshot is that you are allowed to say when something is not working. Strains crop up in most courses of therapy, and when psychologists ask clients to rate how sessions are going and act on the answers, studies have found better outcomes and fewer people dropping out. Trust is built over many sessions. A first one only has to make a start.

What you can do beforehand

  • Write down, in your own words, what you want help with and why you are seeking it now.
  • Think of one recent example you could describe in detail.
  • Note what you have already tried, including any earlier therapy.
  • Bring a list of your medications. For an older relative, bring the medications themselves in a bag, since what is prescribed and what is actually taken can differ.
  • If you will need an interpreter, say so when you book. A professional interpreter is preferable to a family member, and a child should never be asked to do it.
  • Bring your own questions. Time should be left at the end for them.

None of that is compulsory. You can arrive with nothing written down and say you do not know where to begin. The first question is built for exactly that.

References

  1. Code of conduct for psychologists. Psychology Board of Australia
  2. Formulation in Psychology and Psychotherapy: Making Sense of People's Problems. Johnstone and Dallos (eds), Routledge
  3. Handbook of Psychological Assessment (6th ed.). Groth-Marnat and Wright, Wiley, 2016

Make an appointment

Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.

Back to blog