Skip to main content
Frankston PsychologyBook online

Why insomnia treatment asks you to spend less time in bed

How insomnia keeps itself going, what CBT-I involves, what the first weeks are like, where sleeping tablets fit, and who should see a GP first.

Published

The first real instruction in cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) is usually met with disbelief. A person who has been sleeping about five and a half hours a night, and going to bed at ten to give themselves a chance, is asked to stay up until after midnight.

It sounds like the opposite of help. The reasoning behind it is the most useful thing to understand about insomnia.

How insomnia keeps itself going

Clinicians separate three kinds of cause. Some people are prone to poor sleep to begin with, for instance because they tend to worry. Something then sets off a bad patch, such as a family illness. The third kind is whatever keeps the problem going once the trigger has faded, and that is what treatment aims at.

Awkwardly, most of these are reasonable responses to being exhausted:

  • Going to bed early, or staying in bed late, to "catch" more sleep. The same sleep spread over more hours means more time lying awake.
  • Napping, which reduces the pressure to sleep that builds across the day.
  • Lying there trying. After enough nights awake in it, the bed becomes linked with wakefulness and worry.
  • Protecting sleep, for example by never going out in the evening. You never find out whether the bad night you feared would have happened.

Worry in bed, about tomorrow or about not sleeping, raises the body's arousal and makes it harder to fall asleep.

This also explains a common frustration. Advice about caffeine, alcohol and a quiet, dark, cool bedroom (sleep hygiene) is one part of CBT-I, but used alone it has not been shown to treat insomnia. If you have followed it carefully and still sleep badly, that is consistent with the research.

Two weeks with a sleep diary comes first

Before any instructions are given, you keep a diary for at least two weeks. Each morning you note when you went to bed, how long it took to fall asleep, how often and how long you woke, and when you got up. Naps, alcohol and any sleeping tablet go in too.

The diary yields the number that steers treatment: sleep efficiency, the share of your time in bed spent asleep. Six hours asleep in eight hours in bed is 75 per cent. People with insomnia tend to underestimate how much they sleep, and the plan allows for that.

The diary can also show that the problem is something else. A person who reliably falls asleep very late and sleeps long on weekends may have a body clock that runs late, which typically needs a different treatment.

The main parts, in plain words

A sleep window

Your time in bed is set at about what you are sleeping now, plus half an hour or so for falling asleep and the brief wakings that are normal. You choose a getting-up time and keep it every day, weekends included, however the night went. Take someone averaging five and a half hours: their window is six hours, perhaps 12.30 am to 6.30 am.

The aim is to let the drive to sleep build, so that the hours in bed are filled with sleep. The window is reviewed weekly. One treatment manual gives this rule: above 85 per cent efficiency and sleepy in the day, add 15 minutes; below 80 per cent, take 15 off; otherwise leave it. The short window is where treatment starts, and it widens in small steps as sleep becomes more solid.

Rules that reconnect the bed with sleep

  • Go to bed only when sleepy, meaning sleep is close. That is different from feeling tired.
  • If you are not asleep within about 15 to 20 minutes, get up, go to another room and do something quiet until you feel sleepy.
  • Keep the bed for sleep and sex. No phone, television, work or upsetting conversations there.
  • Avoid naps. If one is unavoidable, keep it under an hour and finish it before 3 pm.

Work on the thinking

Planning and problem solving move to a set time early in the evening, when you write down what is likely to keep you awake and the next step for each item. Beliefs about sleep are examined too. "I need eight hours" is a common one, yet even good sleepers do not always get eight hours or wake refreshed.

Relaxation can have a place, though it takes regular practice, and people who try hard to relax can make themselves more tense. For older people, particularly those in pain, a task that fills the mind may suit better at bedtime, such as counting backwards from 1,000 in sevens. It is hard to do that and worry at once.

What the first weeks are honestly like

Many people fear that less time in bed will mean even less sleep, and at first sleep does tend to get shorter, though more solid. Expect to be somewhat sleepy in the daytime, particularly in the first week. Do not drive while drowsy. If the sleepiness becomes marked, say so: the window can be widened, and someone else may need to drive for a while.

As the treatment manuals describe it, CBT-I usually runs for six to eight weekly sessions, and results should not be expected after one or two. Getting up at the same time on weekends is the rule people most often resist, teenagers and young adults especially. Towards the end, time goes to telling an ordinary bad night (good sleepers have them too) from a return of insomnia, and to planning for travel, illness or stress.

Where sleeping tablets fit

This section reports what the published sources say. It is not advice about your own medicines, which is a matter for you and your prescriber.

The Australasian Sleep Association's guidelines list CBT-I as a first-line treatment for insomnia in adults, and the American College of Physicians recommends it ahead of medication as the initial approach. The Australian Psychological Society's 2024 evidence review found support from systematic reviews of randomised trials for CBT-I delivered individually, in groups, by telehealth and as guided self-help. One clinical handbook reports that people find non-drug treatment more acceptable than medication and that its effects last longer. These are findings about groups and do not predict how any one person will respond. The sources also note that there are few data on the long-term safety and effectiveness of medicines prescribed off-label for sleep, or of sleep remedies sold without a prescription.

A person can do CBT-I while taking a prescribed sleeping tablet, and the diary records the nights it is taken. Anyone who wants to reduce or stop plans that with the prescriber and does not do it alone. With some medicines, benzodiazepines among them, stopping suddenly after long use carries a risk of withdrawal seizures.

Who should talk to a GP first

Not all bad sleep is insomnia, and for some people the standard program needs changing. See your GP before starting if any of these apply:

  • loud snoring, pauses in breathing during sleep, or marked daytime sleepiness, which can point to sleep apnoea
  • an urge to move your legs at night that breaks up your sleep
  • pain, a medical condition or a medicine that may be disturbing sleep
  • alcohol or other drugs used to get to sleep
  • a history of mania, hypomania or seizures, because cutting sleep can bring on an episode or a seizure in people who are vulnerable

CBT-I reduces insomnia in people who are also depressed, but it has not consistently improved the depression itself, so depression needs treatment in its own right.

Insomnia usually starts with something that happened to you. It continues because of what you now do about it, which is why the treatment works on the habits and leaves the original cause alone.

References

  1. Evidence-based Psychological Interventions in the Treatment of Mental Disorders: A Literature Review (5th ed.). Australian Psychological Society, 2024
  2. Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders: A Step-by-Step Treatment Manual (6th ed.), chapter 16. Barlow (ed), Guilford Press, 2021
  3. Overcoming Insomnia: A Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Approach, Therapist Guide (2nd ed.). Edinger and Carney, Oxford University Press, 2015
  4. Mental Disorders in Older Adults: Fundamentals of Assessment and Treatment (2nd ed.). Zarit and Zarit, Guilford Press, 2007

Make an appointment

Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.

Back to blog