Behavioural activation for depression: doing comes first
How withdrawal keeps depression going, what activity monitoring and scheduling look like week to week, and what the evidence does and does not show.
Published
"I'll get back to the pool when I've got a bit more energy." "I'll ring her once I feel more like myself."
These are sensible things to say. They follow a rule most of us live by: first you feel like doing something, then you do it. In depression the rule stops working, because losing interest in things is one of the central features of depression itself. The feeling you are waiting for is one of the things that has gone missing, so the wait can be a long one.
Behavioural activation is a treatment for depression built on reversing the order. You act first, according to a plan, and see whether the wanting follows. The clinical texts call waiting for motivation a common mistake, and say people are more likely to feel motivated once they have started something than beforehand.
How pulling back keeps mood low
The thinking behind the treatment is that depression tends to follow a drop in the rewarding parts of a person's life. A job ends, or a relationship does. Someone moves, retires, or is injured and loses the sport that held their week together. Fewer things bring pleasure, a sense of achievement or contact with other people.
Seeing people feels like effort, so you cancel. The bills feel like too much, so they stay in the drawer. Staying home in front of the television is easier than whatever was planned. Each of these brings a small, immediate relief, and the relief is why they turn into habits. But each one also removes another chance of something good happening. Mood drops a little further, and the next invitation is harder again to accept.
The first week is a record, not a plan
You might expect to be handed a list of healthy activities at the first appointment. What usually comes first is an explanation of the cycle above, and then a week of homework that involves changing nothing. You write down, hour by hour, what you did. Beside each entry goes a rating, either for mood out of ten or for two things separately: pleasure, and what psychologists call mastery, meaning a sense of having accomplished something.
There is a reason for doing this on paper. Asked to look back over a week, a person who is depressed will often say every day was bad and nothing stands out. That is how memory behaves in depression: it favours the negative and blurs the detail. A record made at the time shows more. It usually shows very few rewarding activities and long blocks of low-reward ones. It can also show the ratings moving. Say Tuesday's twenty minutes hanging out washing in the sun scored a 4 and the three hours of television afterwards scored a 1. That is a small difference, and it is the first evidence, in the person's own handwriting, that what they do affects how they feel.
Why the plan is small and specific
The next step is a list of activities likely to bring some reward, drawn from three places: things you still enjoy, things you enjoyed before the depression, and things you have thought about trying. You choose them. Then a few go into each day of the coming week at a set time and place. "Walk to the shops at 10 on Tuesday" can be done or not done. "Get more exercise" cannot.
A good week mixes something for achievement, something for pleasure and something with other people. Nothing but chores can leave a tidy house and little pleasure or company.
Size matters more than people expect. Take a man in his fifties, out of work for four months, who arrives with his own plan: gym at six every morning, ten job applications a week, no television. That is too much to take on at once. A first week might instead be a fixed time to get up and one walk with a neighbour on Thursday. If the pile of unopened mail has become overwhelming, the first step may be opening a single envelope during the session. Once a small task is done, the one after it is made slightly harder.
Two details make this more than a timetable. Before each activity you predict how much pleasure or satisfaction it will bring, and afterwards you rate what it did bring. Often the comparison shows people getting more from being active than they predicted. And when a task is done, you are coached to say so to yourself in plain words: I did that even though I didn't feel like it.
When you first go back to something you used to love, it may not feel the way it did. The claim made for it is modest: it is still more likely to give you something than doing nothing is.
Each session then goes over what was planned and what happened, and sets the next week. Most of the work happens between appointments.
How this differs from being told to get out more
"Just get out more" assumes the person has not thought of it. They have. Behavioural activation starts from the plan that was not carried out and asks why.
Practical obstacles come first: time, money, transport, other people's demands. If none of those explains it, attention turns to the thought that got in the way ("there's no point", "I can't do things any more"), and the task is set up as an experiment. Write down what you expect to happen, cook the simple meal, then compare.
The list is also yours. It is not a list of what you ought to be doing, or of what someone else thinks is good for you. What counts as rewarding differs between people and between cultures. For many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, wellbeing is bound up with connections to family, community, culture and Country, and time given to those may belong on the list ahead of a gym membership.
Where it sits among treatments for depression
It is one option among several. The Australian Psychological Society's 2024 review found Level I evidence (meaning support from systematic reviews of randomised trials) for nine psychological treatments for depression in adults, including cognitive behaviour therapy, interpersonal psychotherapy and problem-solving therapy. The UK's NICE guidelines, among others, also support cognitive behaviour therapy. A large meta-analysis found the main therapies give broadly similar results, which is why the choice in therapy is made with the person.
The APS review counted behavioural activation only as one part of cognitive behaviour therapy, so its findings do not speak to it used alone. That evidence comes from individual trials. In the first, published by Jacobson and colleagues in 1996, results for behavioural activation were comparable to those for the full cognitive therapy package. In a 2006 trial by Dimidjian and colleagues, with more severely depressed participants, its results were comparable to those of antidepressant medication, and fewer people dropped out. Trials report averages. They cannot say how any one person will go.
Medication is another option, and one to talk over with a GP. A GP visit is worthwhile anyway, because a physical condition such as an underactive thyroid can lie behind low mood.
Before any activity is planned, a psychologist treating depression will ask directly about thoughts of suicide, because that takes priority over everything else described here. In an emergency call 000; Lifeline is on 13 11 14.
Depression often returns (at least half of people who have one episode have another within ten years), so the last sessions are spent on what to do if mood starts to slide again. By then the first move is a familiar one: skip the wait, and put one small thing in the diary for ten o'clock tomorrow.
References
- Evidence-based Psychological Interventions in the Treatment of Mental Disorders: A Literature Review (5th ed.). Australian Psychological Society, 2024
- Depression in adults: treatment and management (NICE guideline NG222). National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), 2022
- Working Together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Mental Health and Wellbeing Principles and Practice (2nd ed.). Dudgeon, Milroy and Walker (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, 2014
- A component analysis of cognitive-behavioral treatment for depression. Jacobson, Dobson, Truax and colleagues, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 64(2), 295-304, 1996
- Randomized trial of behavioral activation, cognitive therapy, and antidepressant medication in the acute treatment of adults with major depression. Dimidjian, Hollon, Dobson and colleagues, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 74(4), 658-670, 2006
Make an appointment
Book a time online, or call, email or send us a message.